1. No IHRA at Vancouver city council:
A motion was submitted by Councillor Kirby-Yung on July 23, 2019 to adopt the anti-Palestinian definition of the “International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism”, which aims to silence criticism of Israel. The motion was not passed, although it was supported by all five members of the Non-Partisan Association (NPA).
Do you agree that such a definition, that equates criticism of Israel with anti-Semitism, “undermines both the Palestinian struggle for freedom, justice and equality and the global struggle against antisemitism”?
Do you pledge to consult with Palestinian, Arab, Muslim and human rights organizations such as BCCLA when discussing city policies relating to race relations and racism, and to combat all forms of racism?
It is our deeply held belief that the best way to combat hate and violence is by building solidarity across difference. As a result OneCity Councillor Christine Boyle made a motion at council to refer the IRHA definition of anti-semitism to a city advisory committee that could discuss and debate a nuanced and meaningful response to the rise in racist acts we’re seeing across the city, against all sorts of minority communities (including the Jewish community) who deserve a safe city where their livelihoods are not subject to threat and discrimination. As Cllr Boyle has said, “It is my view that criticism of Israeli policies should not be equated with anti-Semitism, and therefore I disagree with the IRHA definition.”
OneCity pledges to continue to consult Palestinian, Arab, Muslim and Jewish communities, along with various human rights organizations when discussing city policies relating to racism.
Further, we believe the global struggle against racism is fundamentally connected to the struggle for climate justice, as it is well-documented that racialized communities face deeper and more extreme climate impacts. Cllr Boyle has led the City’s Climate Emergency work. And OneCity candidates will continue to lead on this and other issues that disproportionately impact marginalized communities.
2. Vancouver Police complicity in Israeli apartheid:
A. On July 8, 2018, Vancouver police chief Adam Palmer hosted Israeli police Major General Avshalom Peled, commander of the Border Police Unit 33 and called him an “insightful leader“. Independent Jewish Voices (IJV), Vancouver called Mr. Peled “notorious for violent suppression of an entire population through widespread human rights violations including extrajudicial killings.”
B. On June 19, 2019, a representative of the Zionist organization, the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA), addressed the Vancouver Police Board where he called on them to “formally adopt the IHRA definition…and to ask relevant units of the VPD to make use of it as a tool”.
There is a growing movement across North America to scrutinize and hold police forces to account. In praising visiting Israeli war criminals and giving a platform for local pro-Israel advocates, the Vancouver Police have been complicit in legitimizing Israeli war crimes and promoting anti-Palestinian racism. We expect better!
Do you support calling on the Vancouver Police to stop exchanges with Israeli police officials and units, and to educate themselves on anti-Palestinian racism and its implications in their relations with the community?
We emplore all city officials, including the VPD, to educate themselves on anti-racism issues, including anti-Palestinian racism and Islamaphobia. As always, the more we learn about each other, the more we’re able to work together and build stronger, healthier communities. We would like to be better informed before commenting on Vancouver Police exchanges with Israeli police.
3. Israeli Apartheid:
International human rights organizations Amnesty International(AI) and Human Rights Watch (HRW), and the Israeli human rights organization B’Tselem, have established that Israel is an apartheid state that practices institutional racism in all of the territories under its control “from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea”.
Please check out Amnesty International’s Aug. 15, 2022 post: “Israel’s Apartheid Against Palestinians: Report & Resources” and Desmond Tutu’s opinion: Israel guilty of apartheid in treatment of Palestinians.
Would you be willing to work towards declaring the city of Vancouver and its institutions as apartheid free zones?
We look forward to hearing debate on this issue.
4. Jewish National Fund (JNF):
The Jewish National Fund(JNF) practices blatant and well-documented discrimination against Palestinians, as it does not lease nor sell any of the properties under its control in Israel to non-Jews, including Palestinian Israeli citizens. Further, a 2019 CBC report revealed that JNF Canada had solicited donations and issued charitable tax receipts for funds to go directly to the Israeli military and to illegal settlements in the occupied territories.
Israeli scholar Uri Davis stated in his comprehensive writings that “Central to the Israeli legal apartheid system is the Jewish National Fund (JNF)”.
Regrettably, the City of Vancouver historically has been complicit in supporting this blatant discrimination through the actions of successive mayors and councillors. This included Mayors who attended JNF fund raising dinners such as Mike Harcourt, Philip Owen, and Larry Campbell to Gordon Campbell who sent greetings to a JNF gala, to the mayoral candidate and city councillor Jim Green who proudly hung a JNF donation certificate at his Vancouver City Hall office.
Do you agree that it is unconscionable and inappropriate for City of Vancouver officials to support or promote an organization that is openly racist and discriminates against an indigenous population, in this case the Palestinians?
We have no intention of supporting the work of the JNF in our capacity as elected leaders or in any other capacity.